FLOWER BEAUTY By Drew Barrymore Forever Wear Long Wear Eyeliner - Creamy + Fade-Resistant - Pencil Tip + Smudge-Proof - Long-Lasting - Forever Brownstone

This is my favorite eyeliner--it had just the right amount of "give" in the actual crayon part to get a perfect line--not too thick or too thin. It has awesome staying power. I am a photographer and oftentimes when I have my camera up to my eye for hours, my makeup ends up looking like I have a black eye. NOT with this one! It barely smudges, but is easy to take off at the end of the day with a makeup wipe. No excessive rubbing necessary. Pretty much cry-proof, for the most part, too. I like the bronze-y color because I don't wear black well. The bronze isn't as harsh on my complexion and is perfect for everyday wear. Love Love Love.

I like this for around the inner eye area for brightening. Runs out fairly quickly though.

Can use on eye water line without any irritation

Pretty color, nice consistency. Smudges easily but in a color like this I like the softness it creates!

This was a fabulous find. This eyeliner stays where i put it and is long lasting. The colors are true. I have 3 colors and like them all.

Love this product and color. It goes great with my complexion (red hair, freckles). It goes on smooth. It doesn't smudge or run.Comes off clean when I wash my face. No excess scrubbing needed.

Great eyeliner for the price point! It is waterproof and does stay put throughout the day. An effective, quality eyeliner for about 1/2 the price of other large makeup lines.

I had ordered the Emerald pencil and loved it. It never smudged. I was excited to try the Black version. When applying, it flaked all over my face and product was actually in my eye. By lunchtime, it had totally smudged under my eyes. On top of that, it would not retract into the pencil to sharpen. Not sure if I received a dud or if the Black is just not a good formula. Won't purchase again.