Eyeko Black Magic: Cocoa Edit Pencil Eyeliner - Brown |8 hour long-lasting Gel formula Waterproof Vegan Eyeliner

Love this eyeliner! It's really hard to find pencil eyeliner that stays on if you have oily skin/eyelids - waterproof doesn't necessarily mean oil-proof. So this has been the best one I've ever tried for this. It's taken me decades to find, and I'm staying with it. The colour is a really nice shade of brown, too.

I bought this after not being able to get the liquid liner. It’s a bit too soft for me and doesn’t last as long as I would like although that does mean it’s easy to remove

I had to return this item - it did not work at all. You twist the lower part but nothing appears. Totally useless.