MAYBELLINETattooStudio Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil, Sharpenable, Longwear, Long Lasting, Pigmented Eyebrow Pencil for Defined Brows, Soft Brown, 1 Count

This eyebrow pencil is great! It goes on smoothly and is just the color I was hoping. I had powder eyebrows done recently to define my sparse eyebrows. The color turned out a super dark ash color. Even surprising my aesthetician. She suggested putting a brown pencil on it to get the warm brown color I wanted. I chose this brand in a light blonde color/#248 (Im blonde). Also because the pencil didn't look too pointy, where I wouldn't get a more all over color. Also it had good reviews.

Really like the color and application. My hair is white with a little gray, this is a good color, not too dark.

I liked how well this wore throughout the day. It doesn't flake off. Definitely a creamy product that brushes well through eyebrows if you're looking for a more natural look. My biggest complaints was how very difficult it was to actually sharpen this pencil; it's made out of plastic and was SO tough and once the stick got short enough, I couldn't even sharpen it anymore due to being unable to grip it hard enough to twist which means wasted product. No good. I also found the makeup itself was so soft/creamy that I ended up wasting product just because it fell out of the stick while sharpening, or it pulled off in chunks as I applied it. So, doesn't feel like I got the full use of it.

I've tried several before, and THIS one stays on all day. Goes on easily too

I only used it maybe 15 times and it wouldnt come out any more. The top was flat and unusable. I saw no way of adjusting it. Very disappointing. I wound up throwing it away. I ordered it again and if i have the same issue I’m sending it back for a refund.

Initially I LOVED this eyebrow pencil. It goes on smoothly (although very dark- even the light blonde is dark), and stays on better than any product I have ever used. Brushing through the brow makes a very natural looking eyebrow.The issues are with the sharpening. The product is soft so putting into a pencil sharpener does not work well and a lot of product is wasted. The edges of the pencil are sharp, so you absolutely have to sharpen the end or you'll scratch yourself when trying to apply it. When the length gets smaller with use, there is no way to sharpen the pencil because it's too small to fit in a sharpener and hold on to at the same time. The manufacturer needs to make it so you can turn the base to get the product to come out the top or maybe have a string to pull that exposes more of the top like the old grease pencils. Then I would give it 5 stars!

Exactly as described

Very short, easily broken pencil lead. Nice color, strokes went on smoothly. But, in 3rd use the lead broke at base and no more was in the pen. I mistakenly thought it might screw up some more.... not in this design. I will go back to old fashioned WOODEN brow pencil that can be sharpened (and has more lead!)