essenceBye Bye Panda Eyes essence Smudge-Proof Volumising and Defining Mascara, Smudge-proof Formula, No. 01 Black, Defining, Natural, Vegan, Perfume-free, 16 ml

My go-to mascara now - never seems to smudge despite me wearing contacts. Wish I’d discovered it years ago.

This is simply the best mascara I’ve ever used. I have bought 5 since Christmas and always end up with panda eyes. I didn’t believe that this was going to be any better. But I was wrong!! I am a terrible eye rubber so I thought it didn’t stand a chance. It is simply brilliant

Love this mascara. Thickening and lots in the tube! Doesn’t run. Does the job. Nice price. And it lasts for ages

I thought I’d try it because I’d seen good write ups however I am a little disappointed. It most definitely left me with panda eyes after only a few hours. It’s a nice creamy formula and ok for the price point but I won’t be purchasing again.

Great mascara

This mascara will do the following ( and ONLY that):NOTHING.It will not lenghten, thicken, it will not be smudge proof, …it is actually hard to think of ONE positive attribute one could bestow on it. No, wait, it’s cheap. But you might as well take the equivalent money and throw that in the bin. Because you will do that with this mascara. Avoid. I hate leaving bad reviews but this product is singularly useless.

Other no smudge or water proof mascaras didn't work for me. I'm in my 40s now and the skin under my eyes is just kind of... Oily. This is the only mascara I found so far that works, but comes off easily at night.

I struggle with smudging mascara. Always have a black line in my eyelids and drives me crazing. This works and doesn’t smudge at all. Great curling effect and lengthens lashes. Highly recommend