365 by Whole Foods MarketUnsweetened Creamy Peanut Butter, 16 oz

This peanut butter has a wonderfully creamy texture and a rich, nutty flavor that I absolutely love. It spreads easily on bread and is perfect for sandwiches, baking, or even eating by the spoonful. The natural ingredients and lack of added sugars are a big plus. However, I did notice that it separates quite a bit, with a layer of oil forming on top, which requires stirring each time. It’s also a bit more expensive than other brands, but the quality makes up for it. Overall, it's a delicious peanut butter, just be prepared for some stirring before enjoying!

I love this peanut butter. It is the best crunchy peanut butter I’ve found without added sugar or hydrogenated oils. My only complaint is that Amazon seems to have a hard time keeping it in stock.Other observation: Folks. Seriously. It’s oily because it doesn’t have hydrogenated oils (the unhealthy oils) to thicken it at room temperature. So yes it is going to be runny at first. Stir it. Well. With a long knife or spoon. Like use some muscle and get the settled parts down at the bottom. Then put it in the refrigerator and keep it there. If you are expecting JIF, get JIF. Also, the crunchy “white pieces” are ground peanut pieces…not bugs. Seriously? You bought crunchy peanut butter. Seeing comments like this makes me wonder how we’ve survived this long as a species.

This peanut butter is a MESS. I opened the jar and it had at least 1/2 to 3/4 inch of thick oil at the top. I get it . Natural peanut butter. HOWEVER - try to mix it and you have one royal mess. The jar is the wrong size to try to mix it while in the jar. So here is my scenario with the product............ I thought at first: 1. YUK ! 2. Ok, looks gross, but I'll mix it and it will be ok. 3. Oh my gosh, spill over the side of the jar and a horrible oily mess and now the oil is all over the counter. 4. Clean up oil on counter, wash side of jar, etc. 5. OK - I'm determined to make my pb&j sandwich, I want my peanut butter , as difficult as this is to get peanut butter in a form that is edible. 6. I get a mixing bowl, dump in the peanut butter, then it doesn't all easily leave the jar, so I take time to scoop the bottom part from the jar to get dry chunks out - 9. This is time consuming ! 7. I then mix this mess of peanut oil and peanut butter in the mixing bowl by hand. 8. Next thought - this is terrible. 9. This peanut butter , in spite of being carefully mixed by hand in a mixing bowl - will never have the needed consistency to actually put on bread - it will soak the bread. 10. In spite of great efforts and care taken, this is very liquidy peanut butter. Too liquid to use on a sandwich, too liquidy to ever buy again. If you want to go to a lot of effort and burn calories prior to making a pb&j, this is your peanut butter. If you want to save even more calories by not being able to make and therefore Eat a pb&j - because the peanut butter never gets thick enough to put on bread, this is your peanut butter. You'll save calories because you can't eat a pb& j even after all of this effort.

Although I ordered creamy, this peanut butter is grainy, like corn meal. It’s also very soupy. The flavor, however, is good.

I’ve tried a lot of peanut butter brands, and this one is decent. The texture is super creamy and spreads easily, which I love. It also has a nice roasted peanut flavor that works great on toast or in smoothies. However, it’s a bit sweeter than I expected, and I prefer something more natural-tasting. Also, the jar is smaller than I thought for the price. Still, it’s convenient with no stirring needed and no oil separation. If you like sweet, smooth peanut butter, this could be a great choice—just not my personal favorite!

This is one of my favourite peanut butters (and possibly the most value for money among those that I do like). Creamy, nutty, just a dash of salt, no additional sweeteners, and absolutely delicious! I eat this on everything - sweet and savoury applications. One of my repeat orders! My only wish is that it would come in a larger bottle.

This is the first time I ordered the peanut butter. It is a little oily, which was a natural part of the peanuts, and kept the peanut butter moist and not dry out as quick. I just took a regular dinner knife and swirled the oil back with the peanut butter, and then turned the jar upside down when not using. When used again, turned it upside right and stirred the oil to the peanut butter. Not a big deal. As you use it the oil becomes less and less; however, the peanut butter is still fresh and not dried out and hard like some others. It is creamy, liked the taste and any salt taste did not notice, and may be its because of the mixing. Liked that it tasted fresh on my sandwich bread; also make toast with peanut butter too.

Lousy Peanut Butter. First I had to drain off about a half inch of oil into the sink. The PB was very watery and you could almost pour it out of the jar. Then it was like they mixed it with sand, very gritty. No good at all.