Eureka: How Invention Happens

Brilliant book. Love the writing and whole concept re invention.

There's an interesting point made by Gavin Weightman in Eureka - the way that many inventions were the brainchild of an amateur, a tinkerer, who managed to get the invention going pretty badly, before it was then picked up elsewhere, typically by a larger organization which carried it forward to become a commercial or practical product. It's certainly true of the five examples he focusses on in the book.These are powered flight, television, the barcode, the PC and the mobile phone (cellphone). In each case, Weightman gives us a long section in which he introduces that individual (or small team) of amateurs, plunges back into their historical antecedents - because invention doesn't come from nowhere, there is plenty of groundwork that precedes it - and then takes us through the detailed work of the amateurs and the way that the invention was then taken up and commercialised.For me, the two best sections were the ones on TV and the barcode, in part because I'd read more detailed books on the other topics. The TV section is interesting because it gives the best balance between Baird and Farnsworth I've seen. In my youth (in the UK) John Logie Baird was the only name you ever heard, while more recently the magnificently named Philo T. Farnsworth has taken centre stage (because unlike Baird, his TV concept was not a dead-end mechanical approach), but Weightman puts both in their rightful positions.The barcode section was particularly interesting because it's something I've never read about, and it's easy to overlook the barcode as an invention, even though it plays a part every time we go shopping, not to mention its role in inventory and stock control. It was fascinating to learn that it was inspired by Morse code. My only real criticism of this chapter is the way that it concentrates solely on the hardware, where the development of the software was equally crucial in the story.These are without doubt interesting stories, but the reason I haven't given the book a higher star rating is that it's not a great read. The historical sections get rather dull and over-detailed (this is particularly the case in the flight section, not helped by jumping around wildly chronologically in a way that really doesn't help the reader. I also think that the central thesis that inventions come from isolated amateurs, which the author presents as if it's a new observation, would have been better if he had read more around the study of creativity and innovation. It's an observation dating back for decades that in the creative field ideas come from individuals, while development tends to come from teams, which is why in part there was a strong historical tendency for the more individual-oriented UK of the early to mid 20th Century to come up with inventions, while the US, where businesses tended to have a stronger team approach, was better at developing those inventions to finished products.The other problem with the thesis is selectivity. It's certainly true that these inventions were the work of amateurs, but it's not true of, say, the laser and a whole host of modern inventions where the technology level is often too high for amateurs to get anywhere in a garage lab. An interesting set of stories, then, but could have been told better and the central thesis could do with some expansion and extra sophistication.

All modern inventions have an ancient history says the author. This is the focus of this entertaining book. He illustrates his account with details of the time it takes for inventions to gestate, for example,the aeroplane, television, mobile phone and personal computer.We learn here about the history of technologies like: silk weaving, wireless and lithography each of which played a key role in the development of a new invention. The author details the eureka moment when a new technology worked for the first time. He shows how once this has happened innovation tends to be rapid.The examples examined in the past such as Leibniz's calculating machine, are fascinating and instructive. The economics of the situation often determined if use was made of a new invention. Reliability, maintenance and the labout force needed were also crucial.Surprisingly, the inventor who makes the key breakthrough is invariably outside the mainstream of existing industry and technology. They are often amateurs. Charles Jenkins made this point in his book published in 1925. He wrote that it is the 'poor man as a rule who sees the vision first'. Vast resources and a state of the art laboratory do not always bring forth a revolutionary invention. Five familiar technologies are focused on to support the author's thesis.Rivalries are discussed. Many inventions are called hair-brained and ignored. The word crank is oft used. But once things that start as a ' home-brew' are shown to be practicable they become a necessity and are quickly adopted.Weightman has written an absorbing account of discovery using five 20th century inventions that have transformed our lives. His choice allows him to discuss a remarkable cast of scientists and amateurs who have enabled us to use and enjoy the aeroplane, television, bar codes, the personal computer and the ubiquitous mobile phone. Not one of these was the work of a lone genius. Struggle, rivalry, luck, ridicule and perseverance fill the pages of this account.Although Weightman at times exaggerates the importance of the amateur, for example they played no part in space travel or the internet, he writes with verve and humour. The 150 years prior to 1939 in America and much of Europe was notable for inventions. It resulted from a willingness to risk huge sums of money on a idea. Today, that seems to have diminished.Highly recommended. Dragon's Den team ought to read. !