e.l.f.Glossy Lip Stain, Long-Lasting, Lightweight Lip Stain For A Sheer Pop Of Color & Subtle Gloss Finish, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Spicy Sienna

I ordered this because ChatGPT said it matched me and it does-for a completely natural look and it seems to actually be staying on. I really enjoy the natural color and the texture of it. It’s not dry. It’s not sticky glossy. It’s just very natural feeling. love love love!

Spicy Sienna is my favorite lip stain. Bar none. Beautiful on my ashy cool toned lips & olive brown skin. It looks complex & understated as a thin layer & more pigmented as two layers. If I could own just one shade of lip color, this would be it! A beautiful, balanced brick red with a hint of coolness. Love it!!!

It does what it says. I wasn't overly impressed with it but I can't say it didn't work. I don't feel as though the color lasts very long through eating and drinking but it does fade subtly. I didn't notice any harsh lines or leftover color. It takes a while for the gloss to dissipate. I have used stains in the past that irritated my skin and this one didn't. It still dried my lips out a bit and I needed gloss after but it didn't cause any chapping or cracks. I do appreciate the little window on the side to let you know when it is getting low. That is really important and I wish more companies would offer that. It had no smell and it did not stain my teeth. Overall I would be willing to try more colors to see if I was a bit more impressed by the results but I think this is a decent product.

I love the way this goes on, feels lighter than a gloss and not sticky at all, but a bit heavier than a oil, in the best way. Also the stain is great! I left the gloss on for two minutes and when I wiped it off it was like I was only wiping off the shine because it was so pigmented! But as other reviewers have said, the colors are way off. I got the Power Mauves color and it's more orangey in color than mauve. I have seen a bunch of other people say the colors are off and I should have listened. Now I have to try and figure out what other color to get since the names don't match the color at all. I'm glad it wasn't a lot of money, otherwise I would be pretty upset at the weird coloring.

I love this stain. It almost reminds me of a pout support type of idea. Very pretty shade of red as well. Lasts for hours. Light slickness and pleasant pigment.

I am obsessed with the e.l.f. Cosmetics Glossy Lip Stain in the shade Pinkies Up! It's the perfect everyday lip color that provides a sheer pop of color with a subtle glossy effect. It’s lightweight, long-wearing, and super comfortable on the lips.Pros:✅ Perfect Shade: The shade Pinkies Up is a gorgeous, soft pink that gives just the right amount of color—nothing too bold or overwhelming, making it ideal for daily wear.✅ Glossy Finish: I love that it gives a glossy finish without being sticky. It adds a subtle shine that keeps my lips looking fresh all day.✅ Long-Lasting: Even though it’s a lip stain, the color stays on for hours, and I don’t have to worry about reapplying constantly.✅ Comfortable & Lightweight: It feels so lightweight and smooth on the lips, with no dryness or cracking. I can wear it all day without it feeling uncomfortable.Bonus:Paired with the e.l.f. Cosmetics Cream Glide Lip Liner, this lip stain makes the perfect lip combo! The lip liner gives great definition and pairs beautifully with the stain for a flawless look.Final Verdict:This Glossy Lip Stain has quickly become my go-to for everyday wear. It’s easy to apply, gives a beautiful glossy finish, and pairs perfectly with the lip liner for a complete lip look. I highly recommend this product if you’re looking for a natural, long-wearing lip color with a subtle shine.Love this combo! 💖

I got the Cinnamon Dreamz shade. Pros: The color is as expected, it doesn’t transfer, feels hydrating, is not sticky. Con: It just disappears for no reason. I put it on just to test the color, and within hours the color was completely gone. I drank some coffee but that is it. I’ve never experienced so little color stay power from a “lip stain”. I honestly wouldn’t even consider this a stain at this point, more of a tinted gloss than anything.

I liked this one. Right after applying it, it looks very glossy, but that doesn’t last long. The color is as shown in the pictures, but it changes slightly throughout the day. The application wand is easy to use. I didn’t notice much dryness, but I think it depends on the day’s humidity and the condition of my lips. It doesn’t have a strong smell, so it’s good for those who are sensitive to strong cosmetic smells. Overall, it’s a good product for the price.