Understanding Thermodynamics (Dover Books on Physics)
J**D
Short and Sweet -- A Gem!
After studying thermo for a bit, I have come to the conclusion that in order to really master it, you first need to understand it from the point of view of an engineer. Then from the point of view of a chemist. And finally, from the point of view of a physicist.This book falls into the first category, so I'd suggest reading it early. It has three great strengths: 1) it is only a hundred pages long, 2) it only treats systems with the very simplest of assumptions like constant heat capacities that are very helpful for the student, and 3) it has a couple of excellent and illuminating examples.The first example involves the thermodynamics of power plants. The second involves a mysterious, hypothetical device that has an input for compressed air and two outlets. The inventor claims that inputing compressed air at certain pressure will result in two output streams of air at different temperatures. Oh, the inventor also claims that the device has no moving parts and no batteries. Is this device possible? Van Ness gives a thermodynamic analysis using both the first and the second laws to show under what conditions such a device is at least consistent with the laws of thermodynamics. And yes, there are such conditions.Then van Ness reveals that such devices, called vortex tubes, actually exist and even have at some limited applications in the real world.These two discussions alone make this book a valuable read for anyone trying to understand the basics of thermodynamics. However, this book is still not a good first book on the subject, and the author is well aware of this fact. He states up front that this book is intended as a supplement rather than a main text.The final chapter is devoted to statistical matters. It seems that no one can write a thermodynamics book without giving into the temptation to say something about the statistical nature of entropy and the second law. Sometimes these discussions are helpful and sometimes they are not. Nonetheless, such treatments are guaranteed to do no justice to statistical mechanics, and this treatment is no exception. I did not care for his treatment of ensembles -- in particular the idea that systems in an ensemble can interact with one another, but it does allow him to get the results he's looking for in a reasonably quick and understandable way. Potentially illuminating or confusing depending, but the bottom line is not to rely on thermodynamics books for explanations of statistical mechanics. And this book loses no points from me for precisely this reason.
M**Y
Easily accessible introduction to thermodynamics
I would recommend the book to everybody interested in physics and at same time to be on upper level than someone who consider popular scientific literature sufficiently difficult. Moreover, undergraduated students of physics or any kind of engineering should read the book before taking courses on thermodynamics to get the essence of it and to better understand this rather complex part of physics.In the first chapter the author uses very simple example with cubes of sugar to explain what is conservation of energy. In subsequent chapters the first law of thermodynamics is introduced and demonstrated in connection with internal combustion engines and thermal power plants. After this, the concept of entropy is discussed and second law of thermodynamics is "derived". In the last chapter, the author brings connection between "macro" thermodynamics and statistical physics paving the way to quantum theory.All above mentioned topics are demonstrated on real-world examples. Used mathematics is simple, the most difficult parts uses Rieman integral.
R**S
Thermodynamics from different angles
We are in 1983, Hendrick is trying to show thermodynamics from different angles using mundane analogies so students can relate to (say before an university course). He starts explaining conservation of energy (first law) using an “unusual” story cooked up by Feynman. You will never forget the first law. NEVER. Because the mother goes incrementally deducing the conservation of energy using sugar cubes. Her son is playing with the sugar cubes in the living room and she just want to know what happens with them as the time goes by. The boy can eat the cubes. Or throw them in a lake or out of a window so squirrels may eat them. By the end of the story, she had figured out the first law of thermodynamics using her own means . This is a powerful methodology because learning becomes very entertaining (Feynman would emphasize that this is the only way of having fun learning).
A**4
Thermodynamics Simplified Effectively
Really well written expose on the intricacies of thermodynamics which are actually seated in the observation of nature! It fortifies the idea that conservation equations (energy conservation, mass conservation, ...., jelly bean and sugar cube conservation) cannot be derived but are observations of nature in the language of Mathematics. Boy, am I going to be articulate about this material when I teach thermodynamics for the second time over next year and part of that expected eloquence is because of the book and the nature in which material is laid out in it. My favorite section, so far, in this book would be that on "reversibilities" and how the quasistatic thermodynamic process has been explicated WITHOUT differential calculus symbols. A truly gentle and highly effective introduction to thermodynamics to undergraduate students, researchers and practicing engineers alike. I now have purchased both the e-book and the paper copy.
N**
Fantastic Book.
I love the intuitive approach used by Dr. Van Ness in this 103 page text and have read it more than once. The book is geared toward conceptual understanding, and is not a rigorous mathematical treatise. Yes, the basic equations are here in elemental form, but this is intended as an intuitive approach for engineers in the early stages of education. I highly recommend this book for anyone challenged by basic thermodynamics concepts or just for fun.
S**Z
Astoundingly easy and enjoyable read
The book is written in a way that is easily understandable by the audience. Not only that, but the tone at which the book is written in is just the right amount of formal and informal, neither strict or silly. One of the best science books I've read to date
L**R
Bom texto motivacional
O texto é uma publicação de aulas dadas pelo autor em 1968 e é um conjunto de discussões "motivacionais" sobre aspectos centrais da termodinâmica (as duas leis, entropia como função de estado, reversibilidade, um toque de Mecânica Estatística) e algumas aplicações, sendo a principal delas o uso em máquinas térmicas para geração de energia (não em detalhe, apenas conceitual).As palestras antecedem imediatamente o grande boom de usinas nucleares operando nos EUA nos anos 1970 e, portanto, refletem um pouco a alta expectativa relativa a essa fonte (na época). Também antecedem as preocupações ambientais que se tornariam globais na referida década e isso também acaba aparecendo no texto.De resto, seria um tanto difícil de acompanhar para quem nunca viu os assuntos antes (o próprio prefácio o indica como um "guia visual", ou seja, uma leitura complementar).Alguns pontos adicionais:- No início do capítulo 2 é mencionado que para o problema de um bloco atritando com outro e sujeito a força externa, escolher o bloco superior como sistema resulta em alguns problemas na hora de analisar o trabalho das forças e usar a Primeira Lei. É possível ver como seria feita essa análise em Sherwood/Bernard Am. J. Phys. 52, 1001 (1984); o segredo no caso é que a distância efetiva de deslocamento no trabalho de atrito não é igual a do centro de massa.- No capítulo 5 a definição de entropia é mostrada para um processo em que a troca de calor é reversível e quase que imediatamente usada num processo irreversível nos parágrafos seguintes. Há uma hipótese implícita ali de que a troca de calor é reversível para o reservatório; esse fato é mencionado no outro livro do autor, mais moderno, sobre termodinâmica de engenharia química, mas não aqui.- Todos os exemplos numéricos são em sistema imperial de unidades (o que pode atrapalhar a leitura rápida, mas não é impeditivo).- Os verdadeiros pontos fortes do texto são, a meu ver: a explicação da Primeira Lei no Capítulo 1 (que é do Feynman), a discussão sobre reversibilidade e processos quasi-estáticos no capítulo 2 e a definição de entropia como função de estado no capítulo 5.
A**A
A perfect book!
Es indispensable leer este libro para cualquier estudiante de física. It's mandatory for any Physics student.
B**I
Short, readable introduction to thermodynamics
I don't know much physics and am teaching myself thermodynamics for fun, and this book was a good introduction. It's pretty short, 100 pages, and gives an intuitive introduction to various topics in thermodynamics and statistical mechanics. It's meant to be a supplementary text, not a main text, so some really important things were omitted, which was confusing to me, but that's understandable.
A**R
Excellent technical content and straight to the point!
I read the whole book in no time before my exams season to reinforce my knowledge on Thermodynamics.My conclusions:- Straight to the point, easy reading.- Very good technical content with right balance of written explanations and mathematical demonstrations (examples/reasoning).- Covers all the basic principles of the discipline (with some practical applications), within 100~ pages
F**E
Libretto splendido
Se volete passare qualche ora a ripassare nozioni base di termodinamica da un punto di vista ingegneristico piu' che fisico, questo libro e' spettacolare.
Trustpilot
2 weeks ago
1 day ago