Clio Gelpresso Waterproof Pencil Gel Eyeliner #4 Dark Choco

This is definitely the best eye pencil I have ever used—the chocolate is just the right color, the formula is smooth, and the wear is excellent.One thing: the cap used to be an ordinary cap (solid color, and clearly a cap) but they have redesigned it. Now the cap appears to be just the business end of the pencil...but empty. I had even started a return for a defective product. I had immediately ordered another, and it arrived before I got to the post office. When it looked the same as the first, I tried taking one apart...and, behold, beneath the fake empty pencil end was the real product! I suspect the same thing happened to another reviewer, below.Not sure why Clio decided to change the cap in this manner, but the product is excellent.

This a nice smooth eyeliner with nice color. However it is advertised as waterproof and it is definitely not. I have to re apply during the day because it rubs off. Overall, it is a nice eyeliner

This is a nice eyeliner that wears really well. It lasts much longer than most eyeliners. It's super creamy and goes on really easily. The only issue I have with it is that it's not really a dark brown, as I expected it to be. It's more of a bronze brown. So I can wear it most of the time but not always. If you want a dark brown color, this is not going to be what you expect, so just be aware of that. It has more of a golden bronze tint to it.

Good color, to difficult to shaepen

Not what i had expected. Color is a lot more reddish than the picture. Its soft and easy to use... Not liking the color on my face

This eyeliner pencil is a good consistency that is easy to apply exactly as I like, and it STAYS PUT. I am a singer in a band and, after only an hour under hot stage lights, every other eyeliner I've used smears into awful raccoon eyes. But this one still looks great after a full show, the load-out, and the afterparty. And it's easy to remove, too -- a few swipes of a baby wipe and it's gone. I will continue to buy this eyeliner and I highly recommend that you try it!

I expected more from this product. It is just a nice dark brown color but it does tend to smudge

Very nice eyeliner. I bought Dark Choco and it's a nice rich brown and highly pigmented. It goes on very smoothly and lasts all day.