Velvet 59 Velvet Rose Lipgloss Noisette

I ordered this to replace a very, very old tube of the original formula of this gloss. It is still the best lipgloss I have ever used, and I have yet to find a suitable replacement. This new version threw out everything that made the original beautiful to use, and replaced it with nothing.Old version:- sheer with just enough tint to give your lips a flush- soft brown rose- cushiony, plush feel- mirror like shine- smells like rosesNew version:- almost completely opaque- intense terracotta pink- thin, greasy feel- not much shine- smells like rancid vegetable oil mixed with plastic

This is a completely different product than it used to be. I’m running low on my gloss so I ordered it before I ran out. They are not the same at all. This is more like a lipstick. You can see from my picture, the lighter one is the gloss that I love so much, the darker is what I got when ordering this. They are supposed to be the same thing and aren’t even close. I’m so sad because this was my favorite gloss ever.

This is my 4th tube of this product and I am extremely disappointed! This was the only lip product I used because of the rose scent and moisturizing formula. Did they reformulate this product? It smells rancid and is drying? I emailed Paris manning and have not heard back? I will not purchase again. I'm sad because I LOVED this product!