the Lip Glossary Pout Polish Collection 4 Moisturizing Lip Glosses, 4 Shades 0.41 Fl Oz / 12.2 Ml Each

I bought this product at Costco and loved the lip glosses. These seemed to be past their prime and would not squeeze out of the tube easily. I had to throw them away.

Of the four lipglosses two were hard and would not come out of the tube. Very disappointed! The other two tubes are fabulous.

Our daughters and I were not in love with this product. I originally bought it because of what it DOESN'T have in it... It is definitely a healthier product than most cosmetics and I'm trying hard to help our daughters make good choices now, while they are teens. However... I recently noticed them in the trash after a couple of months of using them. When I questioned one of the girls, she said it was because it felt kind of "thick" on her lips and she just liked the Burt's Bees feel better. Really wanted to like it.... but just "meh."

Great variety of colors that go on with a slight shimmer. A heads up: these glosses have a slight cooling feeling. I threw out the packaging so I can't confirm if peppermint oil is in the ingredients, but FYI that they all have it.

Great product!!

I received this product for Christmas of 2014. When I first used it, all was great! There was tons of pigment, made my lips feel nice and tasted like chocolate peppermint. However, as of the past few months, when I've tried to use it, all that comes out is the oil. There is no more pigment. I had to squeeze the tube ten minutes until pigment finally started coming out. I attributed this oil problem as a fact that I didn't have them standing upright, so I left it upright like that. I tried to use them today again- lots of oil- PLUS the red tube started gunking out pigment that when I touched it, felt like slime. I was disgusted.

I bought mine on sale from Costco in December 2014. The first color I used was dark red. All was well until August when it started to thicken/solidify! :( At first, I thought it was because I left it in the hot car for too long. So OK, my fault. I put the dark red back in the box and stored it in my closet (hoping that the smooth consistency will return again.) Meanwhile, I started using the beige and dark pink tubes. This time, I made sure not to store them in the hot car. Unfortunately, I lost the dark pink tube after a few weeks of use, so then I was solely using the beige tube. After only 2 months of use, the beige tube started to solidify as well. :( The dark red never recovered so into the trash they go. Now I'm left with just the light pink. I can't return them to Costco anymore b/c I lost the dark pink tube :((

Love that this gloss is pthalate free and a cleaner alternative to other lip products. However, the packaging is ridiculous overkill, very hard to open and environmentally polluting. Would have earned 5 stars but wanted to give them a '1' because of the packaging. Might not purchase again.