WonderskinEyeliner Pencil, 1440 Longwear Brown Eyeliner Pencil - Waterproof, Sharpenable & Smudge Proof

I have used teal eye liner for many years, I have used various brands too as brands stop doing teal. My last eye liner was so soft it transferred to my upper lid not a great look.I was apprehensive buying this product, but when it arrived I was impressed with colour, its a proper teal. I followed instructions when applying it the first time, smudging where I wanted and then let it dry, it was soft to apply, no pulling on ,y eye lids tick, a lovely colour tick. I wore it all day and it didn't transfer to upper lids tick no fading no smudging, brilliant. I never wear makeup overnight but I had to taste if it was still OK in the morning and sure enough it still looked perfect, and so easy to wash off. I'm very impressed with this product.

I think I just found my new favourite eyeliner! I have somewhat watery, hooded eyes, which don’t work well with most pencil eyeliners. Usually by the end of the day it’s worn off. This Wonderskin product is a game changer! I love that it can be smudged or blended when first applied, or if left to set it gives a crisp, sharp line that doesn’t budge at all, it lasts all day and night until removed with make up remover. The Brown Sugar colour is a lovely matte brown, and a little softer and more natural for day-to-day wear than black, and it glides on easily (even on aging skin). I also used it to tight line under my lashes, and again this lasted well, so it’s really versatile too. I can see this giving great value for money, as one application per wear is all you need.

More than I would normally pay for an eyeliner but it stays on the whole day...It also goes on very smoothly and I would buy again.

Why did you choose this product over others?:Great x super long lasting x

Love how it stays on,the problem is it is so soft it is difficult to sharpen there for a lot is wasted a friend of mine suggested to put it in the fridge to harden then sharpen which does work better but not perfect

Colour is lovely. Very easy to apply.

I bought the dark brown eyeliner because I can not get liner to stay in place. This I will not be buying again, it would not go onto my eyes, it clumped and flaked all down my face as if the pencil had dried up and was brittle. I tried numerous times to glide it on, to not avail. I tried to smudge the clumps into a line but it just flaked off. I even sharpened the pencil (or tried to sharpen it) but it made no difference. It was a complete waste of money.

I was a bit dubious about buying yet another eyeliner that ends up being a disappointment. However, this is actually very good. Easy to put on and applies evenly. No dragging or flaking and it stays all day! So good I bought another one of a different colour. I use a make up remover wipe to remove it at night with no hard rubbing needed. My new favourite eyeliner.