I AND LOVE AND YOUSuper Smarty Hearties - Salmon - Grain Free, DHA for Brain and Eye Support, Training Treat, Filler Free, 5oz

My 4 dogs all love these. They go into their bowls at breakfast, but they would eat them as a treat. The problemis that I have to use 6 of these a day. I got these when they were on sale for Black Friday. I will run out in a fewdays, so the three bags will probably not last 2 months. I have used other products and at the regular price I willneed to get something else. They are easily taken by the dogs which is the important thing. Mine are not picky,but will not eat something if they do not like it. I think these are great if you have only one or two dogs. Luckily,all of my dogs are small. Good product for dogs.

I don't know if it is supposed to be like a smoked scent or flavor but when I opened the bag it smells just like a ash tray or a casino in vegas. Is it just me? My dog seems to like them but I can't stand the smell, I can't imagine this being intentional? It's only been a few days so we'll see if my dog continues to like them......but they might be tossed due to my sensitivity to scents. their dog food doesn't have the same issue.

Very hard for my 14 yr old dog to chew.They didn’t have a soft treat - I wanted something to give as a treat that wasmade by the same company since my dog has allergies and she loves theBuffalo & lamb dog food.

I never knew my corgi was so picky..I try to give her something for her joints daily, but she doesn’t like any of it! The vet gave me samples, she refused all of them, and I’ve bought some that I’ve had to just mix with her food to get them in. FInally, I thought I’d found a winner. It’s soft, looks and feels like treats she likes, small enough, but no, again with the refusal. Back to putting them in her food I guess.

Found these treats online and they were only 4.99. They are listed as "training treats". I was pleasantly surprised. Bella LOVES them. They are small for treating while training.I recommend.

While our pup loves her food from this company, I gave her one treat and she ate it. The second time I gave her one she took it, and put it down in the back of our car. It’s been three days and multiple car rides and it is still sitting there. I am hopeful a friend has a dog that likes these, but our girl has zero interest. She usually gobbles down treats!

My fur babies do extremely well with this brand of products. It is holistic, grain free and reasonably priced for the quality. I have been very happy with my fur babies coat and well being while feeding them this food. I would highly recommend this to those of you that are spending way more on equally beneficial dog/cat food.

My dog has arthritis and had previous knee surgeries, so I bought these to help him with mobility. He is 14, and a jack Russell mix. These keep him going on walks, which he loves.