L'Oréal Paris Infallible Black Velvet Liquid Eyeliner, Black, 0.056 oz. (Packaging May Vary)

This was an excellent product when it was on the store shelves. I don’t think it’s made anymore but I searched for it here. I bought a few. A bit dried up but I got my money’s worth. Boo they no longer make it.

Seems like it is dry up already.

It irritates my eyes and makes them water so it rubs off. It is hard to get a thin line

I purchased alot of makeup since it's been almost a year now. I haven't tried the eyeliner yet, but the Victoria Secret Bombshell is the best. I also got some glitter eyeshower byL'Oreal Paris Cosmetics Colour Riche Ultra Matte Highly Pigmented... and in the brown tones, absolutely stunning. I purchased the eyeshower primer also and I can't wait to wash my hair tonight with my new bottle of Herbal Essence which smells so good, I think I could eat it, lol. These products are not going to disappoint so take the chance, you will be so glad you did. I'm never purchasing my makeup from Walmart or any other chain. This even feels like slick but no shine.

I love this product and have been using for years, unfortunately it has become very difficult to find in stores, at least where I live. But be aware that it does not ship well (or may be old) and can arrive completely dried out.

By far my most favorite eyeliner I've ever used- and that includes Mac and other more pricey eyeliners. My big complaint with eyeliner has always been that a few hours after application they smudge, smear, or wear off- always a big mess and a pain in the butt to have to carry eyeliner around so you can fix it and touch it up a dozen times throughout the day. This eyeliner does not give me any of those issues. It stays on perfectly from the time I put it on in the morning, to the time I take it off in the evening when I wash my face. Great eyeliner for a great price I highly recommend it.

I absolutely love this product. I used to be able to find it at CVS. But, with the ease of Amazon ordering, I just reorder it! Great product!!!

Love it. Makes a nice lines and is still going strong after a handful of months

POUBELLE!😞l'encre du crayon est sèche!??! impossible de pouvoir faire une ligne de crayon avec! ... Ils sont expirés! non remboursable.

Great product my wife loves it. The purchase was seamless and the delivery was above expectations. Arrived quickly..thanks

have always liked this product

Yes it did but I really wanted that it should also had a sharp end to get a pointed look