stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Stay All Day Makeup with Fine Brush Tip Lasting Satin Finish, Smudge-Proof & Transfer-Resistant

I've been wearing eyeliner since high school. I'm Japanese, and I love that cat-eye look. But two things drove me crazy: 1) I have a natural eye fold, but it's not large enough to prevent creasing, and 2) most eyeliner has a bulky brush attached to the screw cap that is awful and clumpy.Enter...Stila Liquid Eyeliner. This baby is like a fine sumi ink brush. It goes on like rich, smooth, delicious Sharpie ink. The blacks are bold and intense. The brush doesn't clog or clump or leave flecks of dried eyeliner in your eyes. You can draw a cat-eye. You can draw fake eyelashes. Heck, you can draw tiny designs in the corner of your eyes if you want! And it will stay there all day, in the rain and swimming pool and humidity and sweat, until you remove it with makeup cleanser. Or, if you've had a crazy day and crash on the sofa, you'll wake up with flawless eyeliner (even if your foundation looks like crap).And it lasts, too! I wear a thick band of eyeliner on the tops and bottoms, plus a cat-eye wing, everyday and one stick lasts me a month or two. You can put it on the bottom eyeline as well. I would NOT recommend you line your waterline with it though. The black comes out liquidy (hence the beautiful thin lines), so if it touches your water line it will spread like watercolor paint. It won't sting your eyes at all, but looks gross when the whites of your eyes flood grey. Just dab it out with a q-tip.Instead, keep your eyes very dry. Wipe with toner, then apply eye cream, foundation, and a matte powder. This creates the perfect, dry, smooth surface for your eyeliner. You will have wonderfully crisp, jet black lines. Easy to fill between your eyelashes and create designs. So lovely! If you have slightly oily skin, or leave it bare, this product will not look as nice. Drawing it on unprepped skin gives it a harsh, crude look. The edges of the lines might look jagged or crooked. At minimum, apply a tinted primer.I will buy this product forever. If the company threatens to go under, I'll buy enough of their remaining stock to last until my senior citizen age. I cannot recommend this product enough! Remember, prep your eye area well!

Love this! I’ve never been good with liquid eye liner, so I gave up on it. But this one allows me to apply it so easily. Liquid eyeliner would also smear or crack by the end of the day. This one stays on all day. Great for oily eyelids like mine.

Able to get thin and thick line.Goes on with ease, comfortable pen size to holdStays on

This is my go-to eyeliner. I love how black it is. It dries fairly matte - not too shiny or plastic-y looking. The applicator tip is sturdy and long for perfect winged liner. I can apply a long dramatic wing or keep it short and subtle. It lasts a couple of months with application nearly every day. You can start to tell when it’s close to being finished because the marble inside moves more freely and sounds louder plus the liner isn’t as vibrant. I have it on auto reorder.

So far so good! My eyes water alot after applying makeup and the corners of my eyeliner ends up washing away every morning before I get to work. This has lasted the entire day without smudging or coming off at all. Definitely works great!

I had a really bad day and ugly cried for several hours and am still wearing this eyeliner. Some came off from wiping my eyes with a tissue but absolutely no smudges. This eyeliner is worth every penny and I'm never using anything else. Next I'm going to try swimming and if you wear it after a cry or a sob you'll still look cute. 10/10

Updated Review:So I originally left a 5 star review and was super thrilled with this product! It was the first I'd found that wouldn't smudge with my oily skin. I honestly don't know if something changed when I bought my second tube of eyeliner (the first one lasted me over a year - I will give it credit for that!) or if I just hadn't noticed that it wasn't waterproof the first time. After I got the new one, I decided to start using it on the bottom of my eyes as well, and that's when I started noticing it was smudging more easily and would smear if I had been crying. This is not waterproof. (At least my second tube isn't.) Also, if I rub my eyes (Which you're not supposed to do and is my fault anyway) it smears black everywhere and I have checked to make sure it's the eyeliner and not my mascara that is smearing everywhere. I will say that I still enjoy using it. It does create a beautiful, black line, as thick or as thin as you'd like it. But I have changed my review from 5 stars to 3 stars simply because I have found it's not waterproof.My previous, 5 star review:This is the best eyeliner I've ever found for not smudging. My eyelids tend to get oily throughout the day, leaving even waterproof eyeliner lines above my eyelids from looking up! I was getting so sick of it and but couldn't steadily use eyeliners with the little fine brush. This is literally a marker and you can do thin or thick lines. The ONLY downside is that it dries so fast, it's hard to wipe off if you mess up. You have to use eye makeup remover. Love this!!!Update: I had this eyeliner for more than a year and used it every day. 16 months later, it finally ran out and I love it as much as the day I bought it. You definitely get your money's worth. (I wrote this update before I realized that the second tube wasn't waterproof.)

Love this eyeliner. I have reordered it many times. It is the only one I will use now. Easy to use, easy to wash off. Doesn't flake or get patchy.