INIKA Organic Black Caviar Eye Pencil, 0.05 OZ

I use this eye liner daily and sometimes will go 2 days with the same makeup on (I just touch it up the next morning). This stuff is perfect and I LOVE that it doesn't have all the harsh chemicals like the other brands. It's a softer pencil which I love... I don't have to pull super hard on the skin around my eyes to apply it. It stays put all day, as well. No smudging or melting on my lower or upper lids. I usually apply this liner under my shadow for a faded look on my upper lid. I also apply to my lower 'water line', and I don't have any sensitivity, plus my eyes don't water. I can't even tell it's that close to my eyes. It's an awesome liner, worth the $$, and highly recommended! :)

I’m not convinced this is new. The pencil is about 1.5 inches (3 cm) shorter — a full 20% shorter — than the cardboard box in which it is packaged, which in my experience is unusual. (If it’s not used, it is at least over-packed in terms of box size.) There also was no safety wrapper around the pencil and its cap, which again is usual-and-customary with cosmetic pencils.Apart from that, I’m really glad it’s organic. However, it is not particularly gentle. It should be substantially softer for use near the eye -- "rich and creamy" it certainly is not: It is so hard, it does not go on easily and barely shows up when applied. It also irritates my eyes more than I expected from something labelled for "sensitive eyes."I really wanted to love this pencil, but I am quite disappointed.

Best. Eye liner. Ever. It goes on smoothly and covers well. It doesn't irritate my eyes. And it lasts! I LOVE this liner and won't ever buy any other kind from now on. I've been using it for about 4 months now!

I've been looking for a green organic eye pencil for quite a while. I'm thrilled I found one and I think it is a beautiful color and a very high-quality eyeliner. I am relieved to not be putting toxic chemicals anywhere near my eyes

Love this. Goes on smoothly and easily. Color is good.

I really wanted to like this- especially as it is vegan. The color is great- the pencil chips and splinters when sharpened. In fact, it scratches. Probably the worse eyeliner pencil I have ever used.

I get migraines and am allergic to a lot of products so I was really excited to try this eyeliner but I reacted to it! Not the product's fault, just me. If you don't have histamine issues/migraines than it's a great eyeliner!

Sorry allergic plus smugs off real easy.

I really like this product. It doesn't irritate my eyes taking off my lashes or dry my skin as the previous ones I bought have done. It also stayed on and had a nice consistency. I have now bought two other colours from this range.

Nice easy to use and stays on

I love Inika products and this is no exception

Nice eyeliner, smooth, stays on, sharpens well

This was excellent. No second coat is necessary and a good rich colour. Easy to remove. The sharpener is very sharp and an added bonus.