4-in-1 Dog Training Set, Puppy Training Treats- Dog Treat Training Pouch, Bark Control Whistle, Dog Doorbells, Dog Clicker, Ideal Gift for First Time Pet Owners, Training Dog Owners (Gray)

The bag is really nice with plenty of room for snacks. The clicker can connect to the bag and my puppy responds well. The whistle didn’t work at all. And feels flimsy. But I didn’t want that anyways.

I can't attest to the sturdiness, as I haven't actually used it yet. But all the seams seem well constructed on the treat bag and I don't see an issue with the doorbells, either.The clicker is loud enough to get attention and can be worn around the wrist as it has an expandable wrist band. The whistle works as it should, and is attached to a lanyard to wear around your neck.All in all, a good beginners set all contained in one package!

I am very happy with the products that I ordered. My puppies are learning fast and it has been everything I was wanting them to be! I also received my order very quickly, so I was happy about that to!

Everything is great except the whistle. It doesn’t work at all. Still not bad since everything else was great.

It has really helped is my dog's training.

Good value for the money

liked everything about the products

The threads on the bag is coming undone in some parts but is still holding together. Lots of pockets and room to hold treats, clicker, keys, and phone. It's very useful and helps loads with training and regular walking as well. The clicker is a little too loud so it's only used outside. Haven't found the use for the whistle but it's still pretty good

It is a very good way to help train your puppy with

As expected