L'Oreal ParisPencil Perfect Self-Advancing Eyeliner, Carbon Black, 0.01 fl; oz.

I love the L'oreal line of pencil perfect eyeliners but fear they are being discontinued due to problems finding them in retail stores. Cost of this item was high but not if you can't get anymore. Their new product is terrible-you have to sharpen it and it is a real mess.

I have tried every eyeliner available from cheap to most expensive including powders, liquid and pencils that roll up or you have to sharpen. Since my skin has aged - I can no longer make a continuous line. All other eye liners were hard trying to fill in little age lines without ending up with a jagged line. I read the reviews and decided to buy ELF eye primer. This liner went on smoothly, no jagged lines and it stayed put all afternoon and night - about 10 hours. It was super easy lining right below the lashes on the upper eyelid. I cannot believe how much time I wasted with other products. If you use an angle eyeliner brush over your line - you can smooth without smudging or smudge away!

I was buying this for several months in stores and decided to buy on Amazon with the quarrantine and all. This is a very good eyeliner. Goes on easily unlike others that pull your eyelids. Stays on very well and you can do very fine lines or thicker with ease. Love this and it's all I've used for over a tear now. Thanks!

it’s a good pencil but it’s not a pointy as I would want It to be so I can get the perfect crease but it’s fine I still like it.

I do like how easy it is to apply it, I don’t like how it smudges on its own for some reason. Over all its a good product for the money and the smudging for me personally isn’t a big deal.

Have used these for years, but they're often sold out in stores so I order from Amazon. Easy to use, and gives a nice dark line.

I found this eyeliner and am never going without it again. It makes my eye color pop, and always gives the right amount of definition to my eyeshadows

I last bought this prodcut when I visited America. In comparison to other eyeliners it gives a much more dramatic black finish and lasts well. I am a harsh judge and hard to please when it comes to beauty products as I've been taken in by so many false claims before! However this is a great product and I was sooooo pleased to find it on line as I wasn't able to buy it from the shops.

Perfect for me as I have many allergies.