GraftobianJet Black Cake Eyeliner - Smudge Proof, Long Lasting, Water Activated Pressed Powder Eyeliner for Bold Graphic Liner or Subtle Tightline Effect

It's perfect. I use my MAC 210 precise eyeliner brush (extra-fine tip) and am able to easily and safely do my tightline. Since it's powder to liquid (because you use water), you can adjust opacity and density of the black and make the smoothest lines — it's like painting, drawing. It's not a harsh line like a typical liquid eyeliner you'd get at the store.I can tightline and do a thin line above my lashes for a "no makeup" look where people have no idea I'm wearing eyeliner, and it looks perfect. Also, fun tip, when I need to reload my brush when it's faded, I'll draw a faint line for the "wings" when I do cat eyes. It's at that dry powder faint where it's not very visible and I can lay it out on both eye and make sure it's even. It's fantastic. I can paint a dang masterpiece on my eyes. Also, mistakes are REALLY easy to clean up, just use a slightly damp q-tip. So easy to fix.Also remarkable is that I dropped this thing, and it all broke and fell out. Then I put the big chunks left of the cakeliner back into the pot and added water to make it all stick together again, and it worked! I didn't lose it. For normal makeup, eyeshadow, whatever, I'd have lost the entire thing. But I saved it! Fantastic.With wear, it sticks well and doesn't fade or migrate or whatever for the most part. I don't use eye primer, so that's par for the course, because the rest of my eye makeup fades at the end of the day.I haven't tried this with the Magic Set Mixing & Lining Liquid to make it completely waterproof and smudgeproof, but am planning on getting some soon enough.Best eyeliner I've ever had 💯💯💯

I’ve been searching for a good replacement for the brand I’ve know and loved that stopped making cake liner. This is hands down the best I’ve found so far. Vibrant color, smudge proof and long lasting!!! In love all over again.

I wasn't sure if I liked this product at first, but I have been won over. I had been using Clinique cake eyeliner in natural black for ages but it is more like gray and I wanted something darker. I prefer cake eyeliner because I feel I have more control with it. Also, the line of cake eyeliner is not as sharp as with a bottled eyeliner. I am over 60 so a sharp line does not look best on me. I prefer a slightly blurred line and I can get this by stroking several times with a cake eyeliner. It is difficult to draw symmetrical tails on the outside of my eyes because my lids are slightly drooping and each eye is a little different. What is working best for me is to sketch in a pale line with the Clinique eyeliner and then follow up with the Graftobian eyeliner for the final product. It works great! Graftobian is very black and it is easy to work with. I just mix it with water. If I put it on thickly enough, it will last for about 8 hours. After that, it will fade a little, but probably because I have oily skin. If I need it to stay on longer, I will add bottled eyeliner as a third coat. But for everyday use, Graftobian is sufficient. It also comes off easily with makeup remover which is important to me. It's hard to be sure, but it looks like there is a lot of product in the compact so I expect it will last for a while.

I used up my old clinique cake eyeliner (they last forever) and found that they've discontinued it. LUCKY for me because this is so superior. I couldn't believe how easy it was to control, with the purchase of a very fine brush.Ten times better than any I've used. Hopefully, this one won't be discontinued. Or maybe I should just buy a second one right now!! I can't believe how good this is. Hopefully, they won't discontinue it. Easy to apply and easy to remove. And it stays there all day!

This liner is very light. I had to order black and mix for the right color.

Let me start by saying that I am in no way great at applying makeup. This is the easiest method I have found for applying eyeliner for a tightline up to a dramatic look. I've tried a few liquid eye liner pens and always come back to this. I have purchased this multiple times and will continue to do so. I use a wet brush to apply it on my top lid and I use a dry brush for my bottom lash line. I will wet the brush first before and glide it a little or continue to dab it on a wet spot of the pallet and that seems to work perfect for me. I'm not even sure if that's the recommended way but it's what I do. It's a smooth line. It dries relatively quickly and only smudges if you are trying to do that. I've not had any irritation. The color is a true jet black.

The best water resistant cake eyeliner I ever found was Clinque. Of course, they stopped making it. Big mistake in my opinion. I bought this eyeliner after reading the reviews. I like an eyeliner I can control. It goes on way too dark. If you try and take some of it off it smears. I like a more natural look. Trust me, I have tried every eyeliner out there. I will be returning this.

Easy to apply, gentle on delicate eyelid skin. Lasts all day, but, most importantly, easy to remove. beautifully pigmented color.